The New American Idol

[SUPER DELUXE]

Never posted on this board before. I'm a Sportspicks guy but I just heard someone sing that WILL BE the next American Idol. I'm certain of it.
Her name is Katharine McPhee and she is phenominal. She has it all. I would bet my house on this. Mark my words. Katharine McPhee is the 2006 American Idol.

[starscream's ghost]

she was pretty good

[Wofford29]

she was great, but far too early to predict what this crazy country is going to pick. In my opinion she doesn't need it.

[SUPER DELUXE]

I told you so BUMP.

[SUPER DELUXE]

Wait, america picked the chick with the HUGE rack and marginal talent? Like the 1,000 other times before?

Well, I guess those subversive hom0s and their brookback and their will and grace havent pussified the country after all! :D

Yeah, Rueben Studdard, Fantasia and Bo Bice all fit that description. :rolleyes: Kelly Clarkson isn't in that category either. Point dismissed.
The rest of that is pure babble. You know not of what you speak.

I new this girl had the pipes to win. No way in hell you can say she can't sing.

[Eric Leduc]

Wait, america picked the chick with the HUGE rack and marginal talent? Like the 1,000 other times before?

Well, I guess those subversive hom0s and their brookback and their will and grace havent pussified the country after all! :D
homophobic much?

[alphawhite]

Yeah, Rueben Studdard, Fantasia and Bo Bice all fit that description. :rolleyes: Kelly Clarkson isn't in that category either. Point dismissed.
The rest of that is pure babble. You know not of what you speak.

I new this girl had the pipes to win. No way in hell you can say she can't sing.
Actually Kelly Clarkson is hot, Fantasia well she has arse I guess, & Bo Bice didn't win, it was that Underwood chick *I think* who had a nice rack as well, so......

[MARTHA SPLATTERHEAD]

It ain't over yet sparky. Don't underestamate the power of the Soul Patrol...WOOOOOO!

[grif32]

Never posted on this board before. I'm a Sportspicks guy but I just heard someone sing that WILL BE the next American Idol. I'm certain of it.
Her name is Katharine McPhee and she is phenominal. She has it all. I would bet my house on this. Mark my words. Katharine McPhee is the 2006 American Idol.

She is HOT with a huge rack and wears low cut outfits and thats all that is keeping her in it so far. She is an OK singer. Hell Elliott is a better singer...

Chris

[monkeytrick]

Well, I guess those subversive hom0s and their brookback and their will and grace havent pussified the country after all!


You're a moron.

[SUPER DELUXE]

She is HOT with a huge rack and wears low cut outfits and thats all that is keeping her in it so far. She is an OK singer. Hell Elliott is a better singer...

Chris


Elliot is not a better singer than she is. But you're right. She has the whole package. Her face is flawless. Very marketable. She will be the American Idol as predicted months ago. I called this thing during auditions.

[MARTHA SPLATTERHEAD]

You're a moron.

That is an insult to morons.

[starscream's ghost]

i think we need some pics in here

[MARTHA SPLATTERHEAD]

Circle jerks.
http://i77.photobucket.com/albums/j55/Engelhast/aicirclejerk.jpg

I don't know what is going on here but it looks like Elliot is giving her a BJ.
http://i77.photobucket.com/albums/j55/Engelhast/aiwtf.jpg

[starscream's ghost]

thank you martha!!!!! if she doesn't win, i see a very lucrative life as a stripper/exotic dancer

[SBrooks1]

I would do very naughty things to her :D

http://i66.photobucket.com/albums/h258/smoran79/katharine_cd_cover.png

[COWBOYS_SPURS_LONGHORNS]

I would do very naughty things to her :D

http://i66.photobucket.com/albums/h258/smoran79/katharine_cd_cover.png

SHE's HOT, I only voted because of her looks:D

[MARTHA SPLATTERHEAD]

SHE's HOT, I only voted because of her looks:D

That is the same kinda jackassed thinking that brought us 4 more years of this...
http://www.liquorsnob.com/George-Bush-Toast.jpg

[Matt the Undead]

i think it should be based on Originality- talent is nothing if you sound like everyone else.

[Eric Leduc]

That is the same kinda jackassed thinking that brought us 4 more years of this...
http://www.liquorsnob.com/George-Bush-Toast.jpg
LOL, oh man!

[Eric Leduc]

That is an insult to morons.
I agree.

[Eric Leduc]

you're an expert...
oh no, are you calling me ***? That was such a harsh insult........in the 2nd grade.

[SBrooks1]

Great, turn an American Idol thread into an anti-Bush one. Great job guys.

[MARTHA SPLATTERHEAD]

Great, turn an American Idol thread into an anti-Bush one. Great job guys.

Any thread could be turned into an anti-bush thread...the guy is just THAT bad.

[JayDouble]

That is an insult to morons.

Lol, reminds of the Geiko/Caveman commercial.

[SBrooks1]

Any thread could be turned into an anti-bush thread...the guy is just THAT bad.

I hear there's a new Andrea Yates ride that needs some testing at Disney World. Go check it out.

[NotoriousVesaToskala]

Wow.

That's all I have to say about Katharine McPhee.

[SUPER DELUXE]

Wow.

That's all I have to say about Katharine McPhee.

I agree. Stunning.

[arayban]

I'll be so happy to see this annoying concept and show go away for a little while at least. And yes that is just MY opinion.

[Model Man]

She will be the American Idol as predicted months ago. I called this thing during auditions.

Yep!

[AdrianMonk]

The only good thing to ever come out of this stupid show is Kelly Clarkson, hot and talented!

[MARTHA SPLATTERHEAD]

Taylor Hicks should and is winning it IMO.

[4815162342]

Taylor will win. Guaranteed.
Elliott is the true American Idol though and it should have been Taylor and Elliott in the finale all along.

[dbrooks55]

Chris not winning is a crime! But if Katherine wins that show is the biggest joke ever! Taylor Hicks is your winner without a doubt! Katherine is just waaaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyy to boring and nothing more than a broadway singer!!!! Good bye Katherine, you should have been gone 3 weeks ago!

[MARTHA SPLATTERHEAD]

Chris not winning is a crime! But if Katherine wins that show is the biggest joke ever! Taylor Hicks is your winner without a doubt! Katherine is just waaaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyy to boring and nothing more than a broadway singer!!!! Good bye Katherine, you should have been gone 3 weeks ago!

You should change your name to "The Hammer" because you just nailed it bro.

[Hanky Panky]

I wished they didn't repeat a few of their earlier songs last night, but overall I think Taylor will win this by a decent margin of votes.

Anyone notice Kellie Pickler with the short hair and red tan? Whooooo weeeeeee!

[Sbells]

Pickler went down in the looks bracket with the haircut in my mind.

Taylor won, as I predicted.

[Chachi]

Taylor should win, based on previous voting tendencies, his performance last night, and the law of averages (no white boy has one it yet!) Soul Patrol! Soul Patrol! I won't be watching cuz its Lost Season Finale night baby!

[Model Man]

Taylor won, as I predicted.

Do you already know something we don't?

Katharine SHOULD win as she's a more talented singer (and that's a "qualified" opinion) but I have a feeling it's going to be Taylor. If he does win he also loses because he won't be getting my money from his record. And all you guys who want him to win will have to go out and spend $16 on a CD filled with mediocre, rushed songwriting.

I think Carrie Underpants will be passing the AI torch to the winner.

[whoh8sbacon]

McPheever runs wild in my imagination, but Taylor Hicks should and I feel that he will win this thing.

[dbrooks55]

Do you already know something we don't?

Katharine SHOULD win as she's a more talented singer (and that's a "qualified" opinion) but I have a feeling it's going to be Taylor. If he does win he also loses because he won't be getting my money from his record. And all you guys who want him to win will have to go out and spend $16 on a CD filled with mediocre, rushed songwriting.

I think Carrie Underpants will be passing the AI torch to the winner.
If Katherine wins, you and the other 10 people can have her CD! The other 9 will be her dad buying them. She is an average female vocalist at best, up until the last 2 weeks she only appealed to the 60+ crowd and horny young men. Taylor is original, kind of sounds like Joe ****er or Micheal McDonald...which there is nothing out there like that right now. At least Taylor's single sounds radio friendly...if they put out Katherine's single she will be at fault for millions of car wrecks all over the country! She will put people to sleep at the wheel! If your in love with her look at pictures of her...don't make the rest of us suffer with mediocre sound! Top 3 should have been in no order Taylor, Chris, & Elliott.

[whoh8sbacon]

Hey, anyone not on the East coast make sure you avoid this board like the plague in three hours. Surely someone will spoil who is the winner on here for you if you don't.

[Model Man]

She is an average female vocalist at best.

With this statement you have solidified your ignorance regarding vocal "skill", which is what AI is about regardless of what America has turned it into. What qualifies you to give such a statement? I really want to know your credentials. If you're just the average listener then that's fine. Your opinion would be based on taste and personal preference which cannot be disputed. Is it otherwise?

[MangaSpawn64]

Less talk. More Mcphee pics.

[dbrooks55]

With this statement you have solidified your ignorance regarding vocal "skill", which is what AI is about regardless of what America has turned it into. What qualifies you to give such a statement? I really want to know your credentials. If you're just the average listener then that's fine. Your opinion would be based on taste and personal preference which cannot be disputed. Is it otherwise?
I may have some, maybe I don't! I just stated how feel just as you did. Only I'm right, don't get me wrong she will have a great broadway career. But when it comes to the radio there will be no way she will last, Taylor on the other hand has a shot. Are you her uncle? Did you cry when she sang Over the rainbow? You did, didn't you? Taylor proved himself last night, all Katherine did was prove she could sing 2 songs over again and make her 1st single sound very sub-par. Randy said it was the song because he didn't want to hurt her feelings, and he's probably sick of her spoiled talking back "I didn't pick the song"!

[whoh8sbacon]

Less talk. More Mcphee pics.

http://photos1.blogger.com/blogger/6356/1216/1600/katharinemcpheeyellowdressamericanidol.3.jpg

http://photos1.blogger.com/blogger/6356/1216/1600/katharinemcphee.15.jpg

http://photos1.blogger.com/blogger/6356/1216/1600/katharinemcpheeyellowdressamericanidol.jpg

http://photos1.blogger.com/blogger/6356/1216/1600/americanidolkatharinemcpheeyellowdress.jpg

http://photos1.blogger.com/blogger/6356/1216/1600/katharinemcphee.7.jpg

http://photos1.blogger.com/blogger/6356/1216/1600/katharinemcphee.2.jpg

[dbrooks55]

There is nothing wrong with the pictures I just don't want to hear her sing anymore!!!:D

[MangaSpawn64]

Holy crap !!! Thankyou thankyou thankyou...

*fapfapfap*

[whoh8sbacon]

Yep, I want to defile her like there's no tomorrow, but I could care less if she were mute! ;)

[Short Stack]

McPhee should have done the Meatloaf song she's doing now in the regular competition....

i

[whoh8sbacon]

Meatloaf sure made her look awesome on that song. He was singing like crap.

[Captain Sassy Pants]

With this statement you have solidified your ignorance regarding vocal "skill", which is what AI is about regardless of what America has turned it into. What qualifies you to give such a statement? I really want to know your credentials. If you're just the average listener then that's fine. Your opinion would be based on taste and personal preference which cannot be disputed. Is it otherwise?
And what makes you god of all that is good? She is annoying to me, but because I don't have a "qualified" opinion, it doesn't count? I am sorry, but your whole "holier than thou" thing is getting very tired and repetitive.

I hope she loses. I can't stand the sound of her voice. Especially when she forces herself on the high notes and goes all over the place. I can't even believe she is still in this thing.

[Short Stack]

wow, idol is blowing up big time...

too bad they put bad comedy on the same show with quality such as MJB.

[Short Stack]

I stand corrected...

the clay aiken duet is funny stuff.

[Short Stack]

Prince!

unbelievable.

Idol pulled out all the stops....

if McPhee loses...or wins...either way......The Prince will have her if The Prince wants her.

[nick&vert]

It ain't over yet sparky. Don't underestamate the power of the Soul Patrol...WOOOOOO!
YES!!:D

[Chachi]

was meatloaf Drunk? And this episode proved to me that this is the biggest pile of crap on tv. I am glad taylor won, but the 1 hour and 55 minute before the annoucement were 100 % total overhyped Fox crap!

[AdrianMonk]

Looks like SUPER DELUXE just lost the house! And as for that Mcphee chick, based on those pics, I would definitely place my reproductive organ inside of hers anytime!

[whoh8sbacon]

Never posted on this board before. I'm a Sportspicks guy but I just heard someone sing that WILL BE the next American Idol. I'm certain of it.
Her name is Katharine McPhee and she is phenominal. She has it all. I would bet my house on this. Mark my words. Katharine McPhee is the 2006 American Idol.

When should I come over to pick up the deed?

[JuniorMintz]

Yay!

... Yea, that's pretty much all I have to say about that. That, and a gigantic F.U. to Nick&Vert for posting the results of the show early and ruining it for me! :mad: :mad: :mad:

[Dark Ride]

homophobic much?
Ah yes disagree with a lifestyle and you get labeled by the liberals...

[dbrooks55]

I was totally ticked off when Chris was voted off, he was great on Elvis's Suspicious Minds...Kat severely over sang Can't Help Falling In Love, I already didn't like her at that point but there are certain songs you just don't touch unless you know you can, she shouldn't have done that song. Last night she sounded pretty good. But the time she sang Time of My Life with Taylor, I think his voice was starting to go a little last night. I was very happy with the Soul Patrol pulling through, honestly I don't think the voting was close. They made a big deal of how close it was in prior weeks, nothing was said last night. What was up with Mary J. Blige, is her ego that big that Elliott was only aloud to sing a little of the song. That really ticked me off! Especially with the build up of his mom announcing him!

[Sbells]

Do you already know something we don't?

Katharine SHOULD win as she's a more talented singer (and that's a "qualified" opinion) but I have a feeling it's going to be Taylor. If he does win he also loses because he won't be getting my money from his record. And all you guys who want him to win will have to go out and spend $16 on a CD filled with mediocre, rushed songwriting.

I think Carrie Underpants will be passing the AI torch to the winner.

We all know who won.

We've been through this before. My opinion is just as qualified as yours, so get off of your message board high.

[dbrooks55]

BTW, working at Best Buy does not make you qualified.:D

[MARTHA SPLATTERHEAD]

I just don't get the hate some people have for Idol. If is not like Fox Stormtroopers at the command of Heir Seacrest are marching into your house and making you watch it by gun point in some kinda weird clock work orange experiment.

If you don't like it...don't watch it. If you don't like it why waste so much of your short life complaining about it?

[Sbells]

BTW, working at Best Buy does not make you qualified.:D

He's been a musician for XX years. That's what makes his opinion qualified.

I ate breakfast last Friday. That's what makes my opinion just as qualified as him.

[whoh8sbacon]

I was totally ticked off when Chris was voted off, he was great on Elvis's Suspicious Minds...Kat severely over sang Can't Help Falling In Love, I already didn't like her at that point but there are certain songs you just don't touch unless you know you can, she shouldn't have done that song. Last night she sounded pretty good. But the time she sang Time of My Life with Taylor, I think his voice was starting to go a little last night. I was very happy with the Soul Patrol pulling through, honestly I don't think the voting was close. They made a big deal of how close it was in prior weeks, nothing was said last night. What was up with Mary J. Blige, is her ego that big that Elliott was only aloud to sing a little of the song. That really ticked me off! Especially with the build up of his mom announcing him!

Yeah, Chris was great on "Suspicious Minds", but he sounded like crap on "Little Less Conversation". It was very uninspired and boring.

Yeah, it seemed like Mary J Blige wanted her space on the stage. After she emerged Elliot didn't go near her until the very end of the song. Elliot rocks.

The one that cracked me up was Toni Braxton. She sounded terrible on her duet with Taylor. It seemed like at some points she got lost her place in the song or forgot the words. Taylor should have just sung that by himself. I didn't think anyone was going to perform crappier than Meatloaf, but Toni did it.

Man, Mandisa can really sing that Chaka Khan song. I forgot how much I like her voice. She should have definitely gone further in the competition, certainly further than Paris.

[Scruf]

A few random comments:

I dont know what Model Mans credentials or qualifications are but if you think McPhee was superior to Hicks id like to have yours revoked. She definately has a problem staying in Key and has messed up on quite a few occasions. She'll be great for some Disney movie theme song but that's about it. She's hot as hell tho, no doubt.

Chris sounds like creed for gods sake, i about fell of my couch when he was singing with Live, little and large.

Blige exposed Elliot for the mediocer singer he is, her voice was way too powerfull for him.

On the other hand Taylor made Braxton look like an amateur. And when did Toni Braxton turn into a ****?

That Clay Aiken bit was funny as hell, i think i shat myself at one point.

How the hell did they get Prince to show up?

[MARTHA SPLATTERHEAD]

How the hell did they get Prince to show up?

No doubt, the guy spent years trying to get out from under the industries thumb and touted himself as a "slave." I was surprised to see him show up on the music slave machine show. He thought he had it bad these kids have to do every damn thing the Idol people say when they win without question.

[whoh8sbacon]

How the hell did they get Prince to show up?

Prince has gone on record in the past saying he hated Idol, but I guess just like everyone else they get on the show, Prince needed the press to pump his new album. I thought it was hilarious that he walked off the stage before Seacrest even got near him to say thank you or anything. I figured that Prince just didn't want people to see how small he is, even smaller than the small Ryan Seacrest.

Just heard on the radio today that Dionne Warwick has a new duets album coming out, so that's why she was there.

[Model Man]

Taylor is original, kind of sounds like Joe ****er or Micheal McDonald....

Think about what you just said here.

[Model Man]

I just stated how feel just as you did. Only I'm right, don't get me wrong she will have a great broadway career. But when it comes to the radio there will be no way she will last!

It's not how I feel, it's just a fact. Even Taylor would tell you that. And I don't listen to the radio. Radio blows.

[Model Man]

...but because I don't have a "qualified" opinion, it doesn't count? I am sorry, but your whole "holier than thou" thing is getting very tired and repetitive..

If you carefully re-read my previous post you will find that I said an opinion based on taste is indisputable. And the whole "high horse" thing is your issue. Never said it, never implied it. Stop reading what isn't there. I do however hold some expertise in this area. I can't make you believe me. It's impossible to give proof over the internet. But an opinion based on TASTE is indisputable. If you fall into that category it's good with me, bro. Like I said before, got car trouble?..take it to a mechanic, not a chef.

[Model Man]

I ate breakfast last Friday. That's what makes my opinion just as qualified as him.

Wrong. Do they have non-qualified people as the judges? No. They have people who have been in the business, have seen and heard what works, and know what they're talking about. Now, if you were to ask Randy, Paula and Simon, individually and privately, who is a more vocally skilled singer, all three of them would say Katharine. Taylor winning does not prove he's a more skilled singer. It only proves that majority America likes HIM more. And he does seem like a great guy. I've nothing against him. I just stay focused on AI being a "singing talent" competition. And if you want to REALLY get technical, the very best singer of all the contestants was Mandisa.

[dbrooks55]

What I was saying is they are unique singers, there is no one out there including them that sounds like that right now (Taylor). Katherine sounds like a bunch of female singers out there, not saying she isn't a good singer. You really can't sit here and say you have expertise with about backing it up. That's like me saying "Well I'm Michael Jordan, but I have no way to prove it"! C'mon and even if you do just because you have some kind of back ground doesn't make you know more than the next person. I may not be a musician but I do have alot of creativity and a huge interest in music, which in my mind makes me just as credible as you. When it come to performing which you should know by the way you talk, you don't have to be the best. You can have all the talent in the world and it may not mean anything, Having that "it" factor can be the difference. Taylor has the "it" factor, Kat doesn't.
Now if you want to look stupid and try to argue that, be my guest...

[whoh8sbacon]

Model Man is Ryan Seacrest

[SUPER DELUXE]

When should I come over to pick up the deed?

LOL
Keep in mind I made that prediction during Auditions! Katharine has much more upside and is 1000 times more marketable than Taylor. She just had the wrong songs picked for her. She should have stuck with tunes that showed off her strong points and not messed with crap like Hound Dog! Whoever was making her song picks needs to be slapped around. They cost her the title. No one took me up on that bet anyway!;)

[JuniorMintz]

Actually, I'm pretty sure Katharine picked most of the songs herself... I know she's blaming Clive for that crummy R. Kelly song, but I *think* they get to pick the rest of their songs on their own... well, from the list they're provided, anyway.

I could be wrong though, who knows. :)

[Mattman2]

Where can I collect your house at ,Deluxe? You lost the bet so PAY UP!:D

[Sbells]

Wrong. Do they have non-qualified people as the judges? No. They have people who have been in the business, have seen and heard what works, and know what they're talking about. Now, if you were to ask Randy, Paula and Simon, individually and privately, who is a more vocally skilled singer, all three of them would say Katharine. Taylor winning does not prove he's a more skilled singer. It only proves that majority America likes HIM more. And he does seem like a great guy. I've nothing against him. I just stay focused on AI being a "singing talent" competition. And if you want to REALLY get technical, the very best singer of all the contestants was Mandisa.

I'd like to get even more technical and point out the fact that my post simply pointed out how I'm just as qualified as you are, and all it took was that bowl of Lucky Charms last week.

[Neil]

I watched the auditions only and knew Tayloe Hicks was going to win, does that win me a million?

[MARTHA SPLATTERHEAD]

I watched the auditions only and knew Tayloe Hicks was going to win, does that win me a million?

When I saw Taylor on the auditions I really wanted him to win but I really would never have thought he would. I have no faith in Americans when it comes to voting for what is best versus what is popular. Every week I was like "Well this will be the week that the best guy gets sent home." but I was wrong.

[Model Man]

[QUOTE=dbrooks55]

1) You really can't sit here and say you have expertise with about backing it up.

2) C'mon and even if you do just because you have some kind of back ground doesn't make you know more than the next person. QUOTE]

1) I can tell you why I'm qualified but you don't accept it. I'm not going to argue with someone about what I know to be true. You can believe whatever you want.

2) It certainly does. What it doesn't affect is personal taste.

[Model Man]

I'd like to get even more technical and point out the fact that my post simply pointed out how I'm just as qualified as you are, and all it took was that bowl of Lucky Charms last week.

You're confusing personal taste, which is what your opinion is based on, with cold, hard fact, which is what I base my opinion on due to 34 years of being a musician, playing with other good musicians, subpar musicians, playing in many varied musical situations, listening to good singers, listening to bad singers, and then being able to tell the difference from good, bad, and great. Yes, that does qualifiy me more than your cereal. Sorry you can't handle that. I'm guessing I've been playing longer than you've been alive. Any truth to that?

I'm not knocking Taylor at all, he's pretty good and very entertaining. But when you COMPARE him to Kat VOCALLY, she is in a completely different league altogether. A much higher caliber of vocal skill.

If you don't believe this, then I challenge you to have a chef work on your car next time it needs repairs. Perhaps he can remove the hamburger from the carburetor.

[Model Man]

I could be wrong though, who knows? :)

I do. You're wrong. Clive picked the song for her.

[Model Man]

What I was saying is they are unique singers, there is no one out there including them that sounds like that right now (Taylor). Katherine sounds like a bunch of female singers out there, not saying she isn't a good singer. ...

Name one singer who sounds like Katharine.

On that same note, Chris sounds like EVERY alternative rock singer out there. Totally UNoriginal. He's good, but not original.

[MARTHA SPLATTERHEAD]

she is in a completely different league altogether. A much higher caliber of vocal skill.

Perhaps someday that will be true...she totally has the potential for greatness...but right now she got up in front of America and totally blew it....and it was not just that one song so don't blame Clive for her failure like she is and just get over it.....millions of people think you are wrong about this.

[Model Man]

Perhaps someday that will be true...she totally has the potential for greatness...but right now she got up in front of America and totally blew it....and it was not just that one song so don't blame Clive and get over it.....millions of people think you are wrong about this.

She blew a lot of songs during the season. So did Taylor. A person's voice is often suited for a particular style of music and singing. She had strong and weak nights as did Taylor. I'm not blaming Clive for his song choice, she should've done better but that's that. Yeah, I'm over it. I'm sure she did her best with the amount of rehearsal she had and being completely unfamiliar with the song. THAT makes a huge difference with a singer's performance.

There's one word you left out in your last sentence there..."millions of UNQUALIFIED people think I'm wrong about that.":)

[Sbells]

You're confusing personal taste, which is what your opinion is based on, with cold, hard fact, which is what I base my opinion on due to 34 years of being a musician, playing with other good musicians, subpar musicians, playing in many varied musical situations, listening to good singers, listening to bad singers, and then being able to tell the difference from good, bad, and great. Yes, that does qualifiy me more than your cereal. Sorry you can't handle that. I'm guessing I've been playing longer than you've been alive. Any truth to that?

I'm not knocking Taylor at all, he's pretty good and very entertaining. But when you COMPARE him to Kat VOCALLY, she is in a completely different league altogether. A much higher caliber of vocal skill.

If you don't believe this, then I challenge you to have a chef work on your car next time it needs repairs. Perhaps he can remove the hamburger from the carburetor.

I'm not confusing anything.

I've never debated whether or not Katharine was better vocally. Go back and read the posts if you think otherwise. Overall, Taylor was the best. My qualified opinion (based off of my 2 years as a little league umpire) is what makes this a fact.

It's not much of a guess when you can check my profile to see how old I am. Ironically, I'm not impressed that you've played for 34 years. I find it rather funny that someone who has to be 40 years old (minimum) is on the Spawn.com message board proclaiming his musical greatness to others in a thread about the next American Idol winner.

Keep your outstanding musical performance up, it's gotten you far.

4-LOSW, anyone?

[AS251BR]

I do. You're wrong. Clive picked the song for her.

So, Clive picked all her songs or just that one? I'm pretty sure that was the theme; that Clive picked their song for that week alone, right?

'Cause if that's the case then you need to carefully re-read Juniormintz's post.

[Model Man]

So, Clive picked all her songs or just that one? I'm pretty sure that was the theme; that Clive picked their song for that week alone, right?

'Cause if that's the case then you need to carefully re-read Juniormintz's post.

Clive picked ONE song for her. Randy Jackson, when critiquing her, talked about song choice being crucial. He must've had a momentary mental lapse.

[Model Man]

It's not much of a guess when you can check my profile to see how old I am. Ironically, I'm not impressed that you've played for 34 years. I find it rather funny that someone who has to be 40 years old (minimum) is on the Spawn.com message board proclaiming his musical greatness to others in a thread about the next American Idol winner.

I don't look at profiles.
I'm not trying to impress you.
I'm not proclaiming musical greatness. Just giving you honest credentials to back what I claim.
I didn't start the topic.

Lighten up.:)

I'm done. Take care and God bless.

If you'd like a free CD that I play on, PM me a mailing address and it's yours. See ya.

[oaktown2000]

I thought American Idol as a show was bad enough. But then....I see grown-ups argueing over the internet about American Idol...LOL. Perfect.

[MangaSpawn64]

Less arguing and more pics of that sexy *** McPhee :D

[AS251BR]

Clive picked ONE song for her. Randy Jackson, when critiquing her, talked about song choice being crucial. He must've had a momentary mental lapse.

So in other words, Juniormintz wasn't wrong.

[JuniorMintz]

Yay, I love when JuniorMintz isn't wrong!

I'll just have to remember to dumb things down for everyone next time. ;)

[qwikshot89]

Hey Model I am a big Chris fan. The Show ended for me when he left. But I watched on a little here and there to see the outcome. I couldn't figure out why I did not love Kat. Like she is extremely talented, and gorgeous, what is there not to like. I figured it out in the last week. She sings with no heart. She has the best voice but its like she knows it and just lets the tool do the work. I couldn't relate to her. But Taylor, you can tell with him that he puts every ounce of his being in to his music. I think that is why people have an easier time liking him. He isn't spoiled with talent, he has to work at it. He reminds people of themselves. Don't get me wrong though I think Kat is amazing. But preferred to watch Taylor.

[Chachi]

Anyone watch Idol last night? - My god Kellie Pickler got some work done! And boguht some shoes.....:D

[Model Man]

Her hair style made her look much older than she should. She's prettier than that. Too much make up too. She sounded pretty textbook on that tune. Eh.